Masterson Mashed Potato Salad

When Mom and Dad were first married, Dad decided he wanted to know what mashed potato tasted like so he told Mom (who was anxious to please Dad since she was a new bride) that his mother mashed the potatoes in the potato salad. Back in those days, it cost too much to make long distance phone calls (they lived in California and their families lived in Illinois), so Mom and Dad had to figure out the recipe on their own. This is what they came up with. When they went home a couple of years later, Mom asked Grandma Masterson how she made it. She said she had never heard of it! Dad was just curious and lied to her. He liked it so much that he never told her any different. We have made it this way ever since with just a few minor adjustments. 

This is one of those recipes that doesn't really have measurements.

From Sandi: 

I cook 5lbs of potatoes and mash them (with butter, but no milk). Mix miracle whip, mustard, and vinegar (or pickle juice), (to taste) then mix with potatoes. Add onion and dill relish. After everything is mixed in, add chopped boiled eggs and fold gently. After putting it all in your container, garnish the top with sliced boiled eggs. 

How many eggs? 

Almost 12. Depends on how many slices you want on top. I usually put 4 or 5 in the salad. 

Sherri's Notes 

I use the hand masher so that some of it is lumpy. 

Use about ¾ stick of butter. 

Use the same ingredients for deviled eggs (i.e. mayonnaise vs. miracle whip and Dijon mustard vs. yellow mustard) and the same ratio to taste. 

Deviled eggs (increase amounts according to taste for amount of potatoes): 

 • 1/3 cup mayonnaise

 • 1¼ tsp Dijon mustard

 • 3/4 tsp white vinegar

 • 1/4 tsp salt 

 I used 8 large eggs rather than 12. Cut up 5 in the salad plus the ends of the remaining 3. Then sliced the remaining 3 to put on top. Could have used 9 large eggs and put 4 on top for the 5 lbs. of potatoes.